I’d never been to a hack before – and then I’ve ended up at two in the last week.
I spoke at an event on Friday which is exploring how to improve mapping of cycle routes in Leeds. There are two more “warm-ups” and then the Hack My Route event itself – in the next few weeks. There’s £4500 up for grabs for whoever comes up with the winning prototype.
Yesterday I went to what was termed a Recycle Hack – a Leeds City Council event, facilitated by Abhay Adhikari, looking at how we can improve how we deal with domestic waste in our city. Attendees were primarily council staff – plus a few people who do clever stuff with data, and a couple of interested observers, including me.
There’s a lot going on in Leeds with regards to sharing data more openly – and that was the starting point yesterday too. The council have gathered together a range of data relating to domestic waste, including:
- Bottle banks – locations and amounts of glass collected, by colour
- Amounts of different types of waste collected at Household Refuse Sites
- Information on bin wagon routes
- Data on amount of waste collected on each household waste collection day
- Information on contamination of recyclable waste
The data doesn’t seem to be online yet but I assume it’ll be published soon on Leeds Data Mill.
After a brief run through of the data (more about what data there was, rather than what it showed) we split into groups and began to explore what we might try to do with the information in the spreadsheets – with a focus on working out ways to improve how the city deals with its waste.
Our group focused on what information we thought it might be interesting to study in greater detail. Pretty obvious things – like how different bin routes compare in terms of amount of waste collected, and percentage of waste sent for recycling.
We’d learnt earlier in the morning that all Leeds’ recyclable waste is sent for manual sorting to a privately run facility in Beeston, south Leeds. One data set relates to the level of contamination of recyclable waste – for example by people putting general waste in their green bin – which (if I understood things correctly) in extreme cases can mean that a whole wagon-load of recyclable waste can be rejected and sent to landfill. I left wanting to understand this more. On which routes is there more contaminated waste? Does “contaminated” mean “dirty” or does it mean “too much of the wrong sort of non-recyclable plastic”? How is this dealt with? What solutions might there be?
Another set of data I’d be interested in looking at more relates to areas of Leeds (around Rothwell) where households get food-waste collections. I’d be interested to see what impact that has had on recycling rates – and the amount of non-recyclable waste that’s collected.
In truth we didn’t have loads of time to explore things before we broke for lunch. But we worked with one of the developers, Nick Jackson, (who’s also working with Leeds Empties on this open data project) to explore a few ideas – including improving the page on the Leeds Council website which lets people know when their bins are collected. Apparently 40,000 people visit that page every month – so that’s a significant audience – potentially for information that may encourage people to recycle more.
As you’d expect, as you start to get into detail you realise that there are limitations to the data too. There’s a natural desire to compare performance across the city – how does the prosperous suburb of Adel compare with inner-city Cross Green? But in reality it’s more difficult – as the data gathered about waste collection relates to routes – which take in a number of neighbourhoods. But as the data is explored in more detail other possibilities for better analysis may become apparent. And, with time, there may be possibilities to gather data in different ways.
After the event I got into a few interesting conversations online. I tweeted a picture of a leaflet that we’ve got on our fridge.
— Rob Greenland (@TheSocBiz) January 19, 2015
The leaflet was produced by Leeds University Union – and is aimed primarily at students in the city. The issue that I mentioned before – about green bins being contaminated with non-recyclable waste – is a particular problem in student areas. The leaflet shares information – in an engaging way – about what can and can’t be recycled in Leeds.
I learnt a lot myself – I now know that plastics with numbers 1 2 and 4 on them can be recycled in Leeds – but not others. So, for example, most yoghurt pots can’t go in your green bin, whilst a lot of bottles can – but lots of bottle tops can’t.
Response to the leaflet on Twitter suggested that I’m not alone in being a bit confused about what you can and can’t recycle. So maybe amidst all the talk of data we’ve found one low-tech solution – better information shared with all households. A couple of local councillors picked up on the tweet so it’ll be interesting to see what happens there.
So it was an interesting day. My main interest in this is environmental – but there could be clear financial benefits for the city too. I don’t know the exact figures but dealing with the city’s waste clearly costs council tax payers a lot of money – at a time when the council’s budgets are under severe pressure. So reducing the amount of waste we produce – and recycling more of it – makes sense for all sorts of reasons.
When I get more information about next steps – and when the data is shared – I’ll share it here and on Twitter.